Theoretically, Taking Back Sunday are, and should be, every inch the Trees headliner. They have the songs, they have the sound, and the two combined should create a giant, beautiful moments. This, however, might seem idealistic given their notoriety in recent years for being inconsistent live at best. As tightly as you can cross your fingers for the cards to fall a different way, they struggle to outrun that reputation tonight.
It's by no means a car crash, and they’re buoyed by vocalist Adam Lazzara’s endearing enthusiasm – “I am thoroughly enjoying myself, ladies and gentlemen!” and off-kilter stage chat. “I counted the trees and I got to 1,996 but then I got distracted.” Still, it’s scuffed instead of shiny. The sound seems oddly quiet, while Adam’s voice wavers in places and careens off-key in others. In fact, it almost feels unfocused. While moments like Liar (It Takes One To Know One) are elevated by the joy of the crowd, others are missed opportunities – The One, for example, could have been gorgeous but just feels too wobbly.
As time goes on, the crowd appears to be thinning, the attention of some further back gradually ebbing away. They deliver a saving throw as they sign off with a crowning one-two of Cute Without The ‘E’ (Cut From The Team) and MakeDamnSure, but getting there is a bumpier journey than it should have been. Consequently, it means the night is missing the fully triumphant note you'd want. (EW)